But gosh, before we toast the prince to a butterbeer, we surely are getting way ahead of ourselves.
Unlike the previous installments, which enjoyed greater whimsy in tone and imagination, Prince has clearly restricted Rowlings daydreams from running loose. No token magical creature or significant artifact is introduced, no new Hogwarts subject is shown, heck, even the new Hogwarts teacher has his outrageous dial turned to low. But while some may miss scenery-chewing and thoroughly entertaining hams at the level of Dolores Umbridge or Gilderoy Lockhart, their absence makes way for the presence of a remarkably tight, filler-free plot effectively centered on Harrys relationships. Harrys bonds with his best friends Ron and Hermione, mentor Dumbledore, a (surprise?) love interest as well as his eerily close ties with his archenemy Voldemort are appropriately conjured to the forefront. Chopping off the gratuitous excess that muddled Goblet somewhat and hampered Phoenixs flight, Book six regains the energy that powered Prisoner, the third and arguably the best entry so far. It carries that energy through thirty chapters of whodunit capers and chilling visits to Voldemorts past.
Then subsequent chapters reveal evil and treachery of a different and more harrowing kind, as allegiances cross and criss-cross and the conflict of following duty versus conscience is raised. In Hogwarts, a self-assured Harry is convinced that his long-time rival Draco Malfoy has been employed by Voldemort as one of his Death Eaters. Is he being forced against his will? Harry doesnt know. And when the titular Princes cheat notes in Harrys Potions book help him perform well in class to the eternal purist Hermiones dismay he unknowingly succumbs to doing what is easy rather than doing what is right. Nobody said that being a teenager is easy, as we too see the trio traverse the winding, unpredictable path of being 16. Again, Rowling mixes the right blend of the everyday and the absurd when Ron mistakenly gulps down a love potion and Hermione contemplates buying a daydream out of the box.
"It is our choices that determine who we are, far more than our abilities," Dumbledore has said in the past. And the moral choices that our heroes and villains make are expertly charted here more than in any previous Potter book. When Dumbledore takes Harry to pursue the "flighty temptress of adventure" into the childhood of Tom Riddle via the pensieve, we begin to truly see and empathize with? the boy who would become Lord Voldemort. Like watching Harrys own childhood through a crooked, trick mirror from the circus, we gasp at how close Harry could have grown up to be like Voldemort and how the Dark Lord could have been or could be? redeemed by love. Ahhh, the what-ifs
Though lacking the novelty and freewheeling buoyancy of the earlier volumes, Book six burdens the series with an emotional heft necessary for its hero to truly shine in the finale. This Prince in fact gives Harry the potential to stand side-by-side with other legendary champions of literature when his adventure concludes in two years. And in traveling fearlessly beyond the normal boundaries of childrens fiction, this Prince has visited a frontier few would have expected from its early excursions to enchanted alleys. You dont need a Marauders Map to see that this Prince has opened up glorious possibilities to the heights Harry Potter can soar.