MANILA, Philippines — Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Alan Peter Cayetano defended anew President Rodrigo Duterte’s drug war by making a sweeping claim that all 3,800 people killed under the deadly crackdown were all drug dealers, contradicting the Philippine National Police itself and several surveys.
Police data show 3,850 have "died in police operations," suggesting these are drug suspects who engaged arresting officers in shootouts.
READ: PNP: 6,225 drug-related deaths, no extrajudicial killings
To be sure, the PNP uses the term “suspects” when referring to the fatalities. Under the Philippine law, a person is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
But when asked by British journalist Mehdi Hasan during a recent Al Jazeera interview if “every single one” of the 3,850 casualties in the drug war was a “criminal drug dealer,” Cayetano said: “Yes.”
Quizzed by Hasan about his basis for his claim considering Manila’s supposedly “not democratic way” of solving crime, Cayetano evaded the question and instead defended the police.
"You're absolutely saying it as if you're not on the ground," Cayetano told Hasan, who, in turn, stressed that under normal procedures, drug suspects must be charged and tried first.
In response, Cayetano said: “So you mean in the US or in any country your show is shown, if someone pulls a gun on the police they have to bring them to court first before they fire back? The police are doing what they can.”
Duterte, who easily won the race to Malacañang last year on a brutal law-and-order platform, has stoked international alarm for activating his fierce anti-drug campaign.
Human rights watchdogs said most of the fatalities are extrajudicial killings committed by cops and unknown assailants—a claim that the government has vehemently denied by insisting that police are only killing in self-defense while gangsters are silencing potential witnesses.
But according to a latest Social Weather Stations poll, more than half of Filipinos believe that many of the victims killed by police in the government’s anti-drug campaign did not really put up armed resistance, contrary to the claims of authorities.
A separate SWS poll, meanwhile, revealed that seven out of 10 Filipinos are anxious that they, or anyone they know, might become victims of extrajudicial killings.
READ: SWS: Vast majority of Filipinos think drug suspects should be captured alive | SWS: Majority of Filipinos think ‘nanlaban’ victims didn’t really fight back
In the same interview with Al Jazeera, Cayetano maintained that there are no cases of summary executions in the country.
He also hit the supposed spread of wrong facts in the international community by human rights groups “associated” with the opposition and the Church.
“The point is Filipinos will not support human rights violations. We’re very spiritual people. Whether Muslim or Christian—Filipinos believe in the dignity of life,” he said.
Filipinos have mostly backed Duterte’s drug war even as critics condemned the alleged extrajudicial killings by cops. But the recent deaths of three teenagers in the country’s capital have triggered rare street protests and highlighted concerns about alleged police abuse.
READ: Child killings spark calls for UN probe — Human Rights Watch
‘Can we trust the Philippine police?’
Duterte early this year halted the drug operations nationwide, cussing the PNP as “corrupt to the core.”
He said 60 percent of the 160,000-force was rotten, needing retraining or booting out. A month-long lull followed, but the crackdown was later resumed.
READ: Bato suspends drug war for 'internal cleansing' of PNP | Duterte brings back police into war on drugs
Asked if the PNP can be trusted in carrying out the drug war considering the president’s previous diatribes against cops, Cayetano, in the same interview with Hasan, said Duterte was just using his colorful language.
“Last time I checked, hyperbole and figures of speech are allowed,” Cayetano told Hasan.
“We’re not saying we should trust them, we said we should follow the law which is presumption of regularity but investigate,” he added.
“The point is he’s (Duterte) trying to clean up the police and he admits that there is a problem.”
Asked by Hasan if all drug-related deaths are being investigated, Cayetano replied that “every single one” is under probe.
“Most independent observers have said they there have not been investigations of all those killings,” Hasan retorted.
“Independent investigators have seen the progress. It is the ideological and biased human rights groups,” Cayetano countered Hasan.
According to an updated police data, there are 2,290 "deaths under investigation," which have already been determined to be "drug-related."